Independent agency, serving Ohio since 1998
Coverage you can count on, from an agent who cares
We compare more than 20 top carriers to find you the right coverage at the best rate. Start below and we will call you back the same day with real numbers.
Start your free quote
Takes about a minute. No obligation.
Independent agency
20+ carriers compared
Same day quotes
One agent who knows your name
What can we protect
Pick what you need covered
Home Insurance
Your house, your roof, and everything inside it, at a rate that fits your budget.
Auto Insurance
Full coverage, liability, or multi car. We shop carriers to lower your premium.
Life Insurance
Term or whole life, sized to your family so the people you love stay steady.
Health Insurance
Individual, family, and Medicare plans explained in plain language.
Business Insurance
Liability, property, workers comp, and commercial auto for local shops.
Umbrella Coverage
Extra liability protection layered on top of your home and auto policies.
Most requested
Bundle home and auto and keep the savings
Most families we quote save the most here. We put both policies with the carrier that prices them best together, and you get one renewal date to remember.
Average yearly savings: $580
Also available: renters, condo, motorcycle, boat and RV, and travel coverage. Ask us what fits.
The independent advantage
We work for you, not for one insurance company
Two things matter when you buy insurance: a fair rate, and a real person who picks up. We take both seriously.
01
Independent and unbiased
No company quotas and no pressure. We recommend the policy that is right for you.
02
We shop 20+ carriers
One conversation, many quotes. You see the options side by side and pick.
03
Personal local service
You get a named agent in Columbus, not a call center queue or a chatbot.
04
Here when you file a claim
Call us first. We open the claim, chase the adjuster, and see it through.
A family owned agency in Columbus
Because we are independent, we can shop your coverage across many carriers and show you the honest comparison side by side. You keep the coverage you need and stop paying for the parts you do not.
When something happens, you call us first. We help you start the claim, follow up with the carrier, and stay with you until it is settled.
27
years in Ohio
4,100+
families covered
$580
average savings
How it works
Getting covered takes about ten minutes
1
Tell us about your needs
Share what you are protecting and what you pay now. No paperwork to start.
2
We compare top carriers
We run your details through our carriers and bring back the strongest options.
3
You choose your coverage
We walk through the differences in plain language. You decide, and we handle the switch.
4
We are here for you
Yearly reviews, quick policy changes, and real help the day you file a claim.
Meet the team
The people who answer your call
Karen Delaney
Owner and licensed agent
Karen has written policies in central Ohio for 22 years. She still handles claims calls herself.
PR
Priya Raman
Home and auto specialist
Priya finds the bundle discounts most people miss and explains every line of the quote.
DW
Dana Whitmore
Client care manager
Dana keeps your policy current and follows every claim until the check clears.
Client reviews
What our neighbors say
★★★★★
Karen cut our home and auto bill by $71 a month with better coverage than we had before. She showed us three quotes and never pushed.
Jennifer R.
Grandview Heights, OH
★★★★★
A tree came down on our garage in April. I called Dana at 7am and she had the claim started before I left for work. Repairs were done in three weeks.
Andre T.
Westerville, OH
★★★★★
Our old agent stopped returning calls. Priya answered on the first ring, reviewed both cars and our renters policy, and saved us real money.
Sofia M.
Hilliard, OH
Ready to save on coverage? Get your free quote.
Send us a few details and we will compare carriers for you. Quotes are free, there is no obligation, and we will never sell your information.
Most quotes come back the same day.
Visit or call
Stop by the office in Columbus
Walk in, call, or book a time that works for you. Coffee is on us and quotes are always free.
Insurance Agency1420 Grandview Avenue, Suite 200
Columbus, OH 43212
Office hoursMonday to Friday, 8:30am to 5:30pm
Saturday by appointment. Claims help anytime.
Call or email(614) 555-0142
hello@insuranceagency.com
© OpenStreetMap contributors